I clearly enjoyed this book because I finished it in 4 days and felt bereft once I turned that final page. My very first impression was “Ah, published Harry Potter Fanfiction”. And I have to apologize to Rowell and any fans for that first impression because that is absolutely NOT what this book is. Yes, there are a remarkable amount of similar elements to the HP Universe, but the same can be said of the similarities between Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings.
Carry On carries on the traditional hero orphan trope that is a mainstay in fantasy and adventure plotlines. You have Simon, the orphan supercharged mage who is supposed to save the world and end up with the pretty girl-next-door Agatha. Then there is Baz, Simon’s evil roommate who might be a vampire and might be in love with Simon. And then Penny, Simon’s genius best friend who will sacrifice life and limb to keep him safe.
We open up at their last year at the mage school Watford; Rowell does a worthy job at fleshing out seven years worth of relationships, character growth, and history throughout the novel so the reader never truly feels like they are missing something key about a previous adventure.
The antagonist is the Insidious Humdrum, an entity that has been eating up magic and leaving dead spots where mages can’t cast. The magical premise is unique as well. Spells are from popular sayings, meaning Open Sesame really does open doors because that is what popular belief says it is. This allows the reader to connect with the text a bit more than figuring out the Latin root. Rowell bounces perspectives as well: we read chapters from Simon, Baz, Penny, Agatha, and a few other choice characters that tie the plot together as Simon tries to defeat the Humdrum.
Laced within this epic plot are the less fantastical, though no less engaging, relationship stories between the teenage characters. Will Simon stay with Agatha because she is everything he would ever want? Will Baz silently pine after Simon, and perhaps his blood since he is a suspected vampire? Does Agatha want Baz because she thinks he is a vampire? There are times when I find this type of plot droll and redundant but I could not wait to find out the verdict, just as I couldn’t wait to find out what the Insidious Humdrum truly was.
This is a modern adventure story for the modern reader. The anticipation that is built into this novel is gripping. I couldn’t put it down and hearing that Rowell has a sequel coming out September 24, 2019 has me excited to see what will happen next.
Overall Rating: 4 out of 5.